Home
Calendar
Speedsters
Event-Photos
Engines
Technical
   Construction
     John-Blacks-#917
        WoodCars
        Model-A-Chassis
        Speedster-Design
        Survey
          Survey-Results
          My Boat-Tail
          Other Designs:
            Lines
            RoundTail
            Skiff
            Point-Tail
            Pencil-Tail
            Roadster
            Boat-Tail
        Planking
        CNCRouter
        Model
        Strongback
        Strip-Building
   Bodies
   Heads
   Carbs
   Water-Pumps
   HighPerformance
   RearEnd-Tranny
   Front-Ends
   Wire-Wheels
   Engines
   All-Vintage-Ford
   Clubs-Museums
   Racing
   Hill-Climbs
   Endurance-Runs
   GreatAmericanRace
Historics
Automobilia
Organization
ContactUs

Survey Results

Boat Tail was preferred more than 2:1 over the other designs.  I've decided to build the Boat Tail pictured above.  Click here for more pictures. It is a compromise 2/3 (10") Boat Tail 6" off the Frame which is between the Full (16") Boat Tail (53% Boat Tailers picked) and the High (4" off Frame) Half (8") Boat Tail (37% Boat Tailers picked). My friend Bruce pointed out that some compromise between those designs was probably the right thing. Bob Heistuman's has to watch that he doesn't hit the bottom rear with his Speedster and raising the tail should help eliminate this problem. Several speedster owners favored the Full Boat Tail commenting on the need for storage space. This design gives the same storage space as the Full Boat Tail.

I added a curve at the rear of the cockpit cut out after Art & Frank pointed out it would look better. I've yet to improve the forward curve, but I know it needs work. Our discussion also pointed out that the Boat Tail is drawn in a classical way, but that more modern vehicles have a higher body rear of the seat giving the body more rake which is the modern idiom. I'll go for classical, but its good to be aware of.

My friend Carl pointed out that mixed or edge planking risked looking too busy. I think he is right, but the planks have to resolve someplace and the edge planking makes them resolve in the least construction risk place.... also with all planks of matching wood, the busyness should be muted.

Several people said that the Model A was the wrong car for a Roadster Body... it needed a lower V8 chassis.... I thought that was correct. A couple of people wanted the car shortened or lengthened... I thought it was as short as it could be and still bend the rear deck planks... and any longer and it risked looking rear end heavy. A couple of people commented that they would like a concave sided skiff like '23 Amilcar .... the Model A frame is too wide at the rear to get the concave sides, but I think they are right. My first impression was between the Boat Tail and the Roadster. The survey helped me understand why I liked the Boat Tail.

Survey Results


I asked opinions from about 100 people and about 2/3s responded. I looked at the results counting only my most respected friends, my artistic friends, my automotive friends, everyone who responded.... the percentages came out almost the same every way I cut it. The questionaire can be viewed at http://www.jcblack.com/WhichSpeedster/QuickTest.shtml

Question #1 
  38% Boat Tail
  11% Skiff
  19% Point Tail Roadster
    0% Pencil Tail
  18% Roadster
  15% Round Tail

Question #2
  60% Edge Planked
  24% Mixed
  16% Center Planked

Question #3
  Boat Tail
    52% Full
    39% High Half
      9% Mid Height Half

  Round Tail
    55% Thick
    40% Thin

No Pencil Tail votes.

More Pictures 2/3 Boat Tail

Click Photos to Enlarge

Home  ||  Calendar  ||  Speedsters  ||  Events  ||  Engines  ||  Technical  ||  Historics  ||  Organization  ||  Contact Us

Copyright 2002 and succeeding years -- Northwest Vintage Speedsters

Suggestions or Comments on Our Web Site ?
Contact : WebMaster at nwvs.org